{"store":{"baseInfo":{"podcastTitle":"The Sunday Shiur By Rabbi Yoel Plutchok","slug":"TheSundayShiur","podcastDescription":"Exploring Halacha and Minhag through the lens of history","podcastLogo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv.jpg","podcastShareLogo":"https://d2bwo9zemjwxh5.cloudfront.net/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv_1200x628.jpg?s=c7cf883f7282e2f818dae48ef380ab08&e=jpg","podcastUrl":"https://TheSundayShiur.podbean.com","podcastCanSearched":true,"feedUrl":"https://feed.podbean.com/TheSundayShiur/feed.xml","theme":"elegant","podcastDeepLink":"https://www.podbean.com/pw/pbblog-k5u37-fa7870?from=usersite","removePodbeanBranding":"no","brandingLogo":null,"timeZone":{"timeZoneId":17,"gmtAdjustment":"GMT-04:00","useDaylightTime":1,"value":-4,"text":"(GMT-04:00) Atlantic Time (Canada)","daylightStartTime":"Second Sunday Of March +2 Hours","daylightEndTime":"First Sunday Of November +2 Hours","timezone":"America/Halifax"},"podcastDownloads":null,"totalEpisodes":170,"showComments":true,"iOSAppDownloadLink":null,"customizeCssUrl":null,"androidAppDownloadLink":null,"showPostShare":true,"showLike":true,"author":"R Yoel Pluchok","enableEngagementStats":true,"shareEmbedLink":"https://admin5.podbean.com/embed.html?id=pbblog-k5u37-fa7870-playlist","language":"en","sensitivitySessionExpireTime":3600,"podcastApps":[{"name":"Apple Podcasts","link":"https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-sunday-shiur-by-rabbi-yoel-plutchok/id1686817830","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/apple-podcast.png","title":null},{"name":"Podbean App","link":"https://www.podbean.com/pw/pbblog-k5u37-fa7870?from=usersite","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/podbean-app.png","title":null},{"name":"Spotify","link":"https://open.spotify.com/show/2lyj3hw8tjEhjMMX2JHvaW","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/spotify.png","title":null},{"name":"Amazon Music","link":"https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/f66daf4c-b4f9-4686-b542-83abdcbe4c53","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/AmazonMusic.png","title":null},{"name":"iHeartRadio","link":"https://iheart.com/podcast/114637939","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/iHeartRadio.png","title":null},{"name":"PlayerFM","link":"https://player.fm/series/3473925","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/PlayerFM.png","title":null},{"name":"Podchaser","link":"https://www.podchaser.com/podcasts/the-sunday-shiur-by-rabbi-yoel-5322213","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/Podchaser.webp","title":null},{"name":"BoomPlay","link":"https://www.boomplaymusic.com/podcasts/65321","image":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1/site/images/admin5/BoomPlay.png","title":null}],"components":{"base":[{"id":"MainStyle","val":"light"},{"id":"Font","val":"Avenir"},{"id":"SecondaryFont","val":"Avenir"},{"id":"PlayerColor","val":"#8fc31f"},{"id":"PlayerStyle","val":"player1"},{"id":"PlayerWave","val":"show"},{"id":"Favicon","val":null},{"id":"CookiesNotice","val":"hide"},{"id":"CookiesNoticeContent","val":"

Cookies Notice

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies.

"}],"home-header":[{"id":"HomeHeaderTextColor","val":"#000000"},{"id":"HomeHeaderBackgroundColor","val":"#ffffff"}],"page-header":[{"id":"PageHeaderTextColor","val":"#ffffff"},{"id":"PageHeaderBackgroundColor","val":"#868686"}],"episode-list":[{"id":"EpisodeListType","val":"grid"},{"id":"EpisodesPerPage","val":10},{"id":"EpisodeStats","val":"show"}],"navigation":[{"id":"NavigationFontColor","val":"#000000"},{"id":"NavigationBackgroundColor","val":"#e9e9e9"},{"id":"NavigationSearch","val":"show"},{"id":"NavigationLinks","val":[{"id":"Home","type":"Link","value":"/","text":"Home","subitems":[]},{"id":"Subscribe","type":"Link","value":"https://www.podbean.com/site/podcatcher/index/blog/AmgwzgtApCl8","text":"Subscribe","subitems":[]},{"id":"Profile","type":"Link","value":"https://www.podbean.com/user-jlYKx3tdpun0","text":"Profile","subitems":[]}]}],"footer":[{"id":"FooterType","val":"Footer2"},{"id":"FooterFontColor","val":"#ffffff"},{"id":"FooterBackgroundColor","val":"#000000"},{"id":"FooterCopyright","val":"Copyright 2023 All rights reserved."},{"id":"SocialMediaLinks","val":{"facebook_username":"","twitter_username":"","instagram_username":"","youtube_username":"","linkedin_username":""}}],"customize-container1":[],"customize-container2":[]},"allLinks":[],"mainStylesDefaultSettings":null,"defaultCustomizeComponents":null,"scripts":[],"metas":null,"appConfig":{"package":"com.podbean.app.podcast","app_store_id":973361050,"app_name":"Podbean","scheme":"podbean"},"customizeCss":null,"canEditCss":null,"enableJsCodeInCustomizeContent":false,"enabledIframeCodeInCustomizeContent":true,"sectionMaxCount":10,"enableEditorLink":true,"enableEditCookiesNotice":true,"siteRedirectToFeed":false,"podcatcherRssUrl":null,"showFeed":true,"showTopBar":true,"enableWebSiteLike":true,"organizationName":null,"organizationPageLink":null},"backToListUrl":"/","tinymceLoaded":false,"listEpisodes":[],"userLikedEpisodes":[],"userLikeCheckedEpisodes":[],"topBarIframeLoaded":false,"listTotalCount":0,"listTotalPage":0,"listPage":0,"listType":"all","listValue":"","listName":"","pageLoading":false,"apiBaseUrl":"https://thesundayshiur.podbean.com","apiCommonParams":{"t":"6889a277","clientSignature":"c0de92add2bee0482da127290af16669","u":null,"customizing":null},"apiCommonHeaders":{},"comments":[],"commentsTotalCount":0,"commentsTotalPage":0,"commentsPage":1,"commentEpisodeId":"pb21862357-nksyz","episode":{"id":"pb21862357","idTag":"nksyz","title":"Sterlit Cavier: The Hungarian fish controversy","logo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv_300x300.jpg","shareLogo":"https://d2bwo9zemjwxh5.cloudfront.net/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv_1200x628.jpg?s=c7cf883f7282e2f818dae48ef380ab08&e=jpg","largeLogo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv.jpg","previewContent":null,"content":"

The Ramban’s definition and experiment

The Nodeh Beyehuda’s grand heter

Ahron Charaner and the “Tik Fish” controversy

Reb Yitzchok Grishiver , the Nodeh Beyhuda’s “chazara” and R Shmuel Landau’s fiery response

The ensuing controversy and motives revealed

When emes is sheker and sheker is emes - Reb Akiva, the Chassam Sofer, and Reb Yaakov Kamanetsky

","publishTimestamp":1697987038,"duration":2380,"mediaUrl":"https://mcdn.podbean.com/mf/web/xsaqra/WhatsApp_Audio_2023-10-22_at_104523_AM7my4g.mp3","mediaType":"audio/mpeg","shareLink":"https://admin5.podbean.com/embed.html?id=pb-nksyz-14d97d5","likedCount":0,"deepLink":"https://www.podbean.com/ew/pb-nksyz-14d97d5","transcriptUrl":null,"permalink":"/e/sterlit-cavier-the-hungarian-fish-controversy/","downloadLink":"https://www.podbean.com/media/share/pb-nksyz-14d97d5?download=1","fallbackResource":null,"fallbackResourceMimetype":null,"downloadCount":254,"status":"publish","hasMoreContent":false,"chaptersUrl":null,"explicit":false},"episodeShareLink":null,"deepLink":"https://www.podbean.com/ew/pb-nksyz-14d97d5","playlist":{"episodes":[],"current":0,"start":0,"stop":0,"playing":true,"playerLoading":true,"playbackRate":1,"playbackRateIndex":1,"volume":1},"toasts":[],"confirm":null,"customizeEditorFormZIndex":999,"lastRequestTime":null,"validateChangesOnBeforeunload":true,"windowWidth":1000,"VITE_FS1_CDN_URL_PREFIX":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/fs1","reloadStats":false,"userIdEncrypted":null,"userProfilePicture":null,"username":null,"isVerified":false,"loadUserInfo":false,"loginUrl":"https://www.podbean.com/site/user/login?return=https%253A%252F%252FTheSundayShiur.podbean.com%252Fe%252Fsterlit-cavier-the-hungarian-fish-controversy%252F&rts=2262d4e1ba0e05ab9cc9ccef4af5dc1fce59a5b5","recaptchaV3Loaded":false,"recaptchaV2Loaded":false,"likesLoaded":false,"commentLikeMap":{},"commentOffset":0},"episode":{"id":"pb21862357","idTag":"nksyz","title":"Sterlit Cavier: The Hungarian fish controversy","logo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv_300x300.jpg","shareLogo":"https://d2bwo9zemjwxh5.cloudfront.net/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv_1200x628.jpg?s=c7cf883f7282e2f818dae48ef380ab08&e=jpg","largeLogo":"https://pbcdn1.podbean.com/imglogo/image-logo/16414832/My_project_1_95svnv.jpg","previewContent":null,"content":"

The Ramban’s definition and experiment

The Nodeh Beyehuda’s grand heter

Ahron Charaner and the “Tik Fish” controversy

Reb Yitzchok Grishiver , the Nodeh Beyhuda’s “chazara” and R Shmuel Landau’s fiery response

The ensuing controversy and motives revealed

When emes is sheker and sheker is emes - Reb Akiva, the Chassam Sofer, and Reb Yaakov Kamanetsky